Jason Claridge, Director and Personal Injury and Clinical Negligence Lawyer at Ward and Rider Solicitors recently acted for Mr X (his name has been changed). He had worked for a number of years delivering various windscreens and sunroofs for his then employers. These varied in weight and size. They were covered by the manual handling regulations. The biggest screens we argued should’ve required aids and equipment or manual assistance when he was delivering them. This was not available to him.
There are a number of different issues in resect of this case which were raised by the defendants. Firstly, they argued that his date of knowledge was earlier than he alleged. Essentially, he has, like other Claimants, 3 years from the date of knowing or ought to be aware of the fact that the working systems are damaging his back. We argue that they were not correct. That it would’ve been a fair few months after the back symptoms first began to affect him, that he would recognise that it was down to work as opposed to other factors in his life, as he was a keen golfer at the same time as the individual who would like to go and watch bands play which meant that he was standing on his feet for long periods.
They then argued that although they owed a duty of care to him as an employee, they had not breached their duty of care. They said that the weights were not particularly heavy, they said that he had never asked for any assistance. We argued that their own disclosure showed that some of the windscreens weighed up to 45 kilos. That at the warehouse they would have two people load the van that he was driving. That when he was delivering the windscreens, he was delivering them without any assistance. That he was carrying them in the dark, often in rainy or windy or both in terms of weather conditions which made carrying the windscreens much more difficult and that he had requested assistance in the past from his manager but as he was working mainly at night, he was advised that such assistance was not available.
As a result of their stance, the court granted both parties leave to obtain their own expert evidence from engineers in respect of the working practises. Both pieties experts came to different conclusions, with our expert taking the view that his working systems were a breach to the manual handling regulations and the defendants experts taking the view that they were not.
We then faced an argument on the issue of the causal link between the way in which he was working and his back problems. Both parties obtained medical reports from specialist spinal surgeons. Both experts accepted that he had degenerative changes showing on an MRI scan of his spine. However, our expert argued that just because he had degenerative changes it wouldn’t mean that he wouldn’t have been suffering from the same symptoms and that what he had in fact suffered was a triggering of symptoms as a consequence of the repetitive heavy and awkward lifting.
Their spinal expert said that his degenerative changed were naturally occurring. That consequently all of the symptoms that he was experiencing were down to naturally occurring degenerative changes. That the fact he was repeatedly lifting heavy and awkward windscreens had no bearing at all on the duration or severity of his symptoms.
Both spinal experts deferred to pain management experts for a prognosis because this is what the clinical practise and the NHS now tends to follow. Both parties have leave of the court to instruct a pain management expert. Our expert instructed for the claimant took the view that he had suffered chronic pain as a consequence of this work and that without treatment he would be left with ongoing pain. As liability was in dispute, the defendants refused to fund such treatment, and the NHS could not fund it due to resourcing restrictions.
The defendants pain management expert took the view that he may, if you could establish breach of duty and causation, suffer some pain and discomfort whilst at work but this would stop once he had finished work.
Apart from his injuries, we claimed a modest amount of help and assistance for his sister to help him with the shopping. He also had some costs incurred in terms of taking pain killers and some private physiotherapy.
However, as a consequence of what happened to him at work, he was unable to continue work. He received state benefits in the form of universal credit, the rules regarding benefits are that where they qualify, such benefits need to be repaid out of any compensation and in this case, the universal credit figure of just under £35,000 was offset against his loss of earnings claim. This was repaid in full by the defendants. He was close to retirement age. Unfortunately, he did not find another job after he left the defendants company and before he retired.
In light of the various risks involved in his case, after a period of negotiation of offers and counter offers being sent between the parties. He accepted the sum of £32,000 plus the repayment of the benefits which was around £35,000 which meant that the total award of compensation would be in the region of £67,000.
Although we felt he had the stronger case, there were a number of risk factors which meant that he could lose his claim or have the award for compensation substantially reduced due to the expert engineering evidence, the spinal expert evidence and the pain management expert evidence produced and disclosed by the defendant’s solicitors. He was advised throughout by Jason Claridge and barristers and ultimately decided that he wanted to accept the last offer made.
He had an intention of topping up his pension and putting something by for a rainy day as well as having a holiday with his family.
This is a true personal injury case. His name has been changed. It was run on a no win no fee basis. i.e. conditional fee agreement.
Please contact us if you have any questions about heavy repetitive lifting or manual handling cases as well as general employers’ liability cases, road traffic accident cases, tripping and slipping cases and clinical negligence cases. The firm will undertake such work on a conditional fee basis, no win no fee.